NaOnka and Purple Kelly went through pretty different things throughout the past 28 days on Survivor. One kept quiet (or so we thought) while the other pulled off controversy after controversy in order to stay. And then, in one night, both of them quit. Here's my question, then: who had a better reason to quit? Was it NaOnka, whose joints were freezing during the cold? Or was it Purple Kelly, who, well... what did she do anyway?

I think NaOnka had a better reason to quit, I mean it wasn't like she was going to win anyways. I really don't think that Purple Kelly did anything to make her tired or anything, in all the scenes she was in she just sat in the shelter complaining, and it didn't look like she did much during challenges. I could be wrong though, but at least NaOnka did try.

NEITHER!! You just don't quit Survivor on day 28! And watchig Alina, Marty and Brenda's faces on the jury and Alina crying hurt so much it's almost insane. Oh my God... I say this again, I do not want to ever see them again in Survivor. But I'm looking forward to the Reunion show!

NaOnka has no right to complain about her joints. Dan is still surviving and he has two bad bad knees!!!!!

I'll admit, Dan is a trooper - he's becoming pretty much like Purple Kelly, someone you root for to go to the end (but not necessarily win)...

I think NaOnka had a better reason to quit. I mean she had no shot of winning, but based on what was happening in the game Kelly had a great chance to win (not on her edit, obviously). She didnt really piss anyone off and probably could have been another Natalie/Amber had she clung onto Holly or Chase or someone.

Neither had a good reason. Only if there is a medical issue should you be allowed to leave. If you are really stranded on an island, you do not get to go home just because you want to.