The 'American Idol' Top 11: Who's Going Home?
The 'American Idol' Top 11: Who's Going Home?
We all know that whoever gets eliminated at this point in American Idol doesn't just lose a shot at the big prize. The person that gets the boot tonight also loses the chance to participate in the American Idol summer tour, which is a good way to get publicity and some bucks off ticket sales. With that in mind, last night should've been pretty good, right?

Well, it wasn't the most memorable thing, really. In fact, some of us would rather forget it. Mind you, we're only referring to most of the performances last night, not all of it. That's pretty evident from the numbers we're crunching today: the poll numbers are landslides, and my bottom three is the exact same as Abbey's bottom three. Fantasy TV is saying the same thing, too. Does that mean tonight's elimination is an absolute certainty?

Not all titles featured on BuddyTV are available through Amazon Prime.


Your FantasyTV Picks for Elimination:

Paige Miles - 67%
Tim Urban - 13%
Andrew Garcia - 10%

Poll results from last night's live thoughts:


Best performance of the night:

Crystal Bowersox's "Me and Bobby McGee": 61%
Siobhan Magnus' "Superstition": 14%
Casey James' "The Power of Love": 11%

Worst performance of the night:

Paige Miles' "Against All Odds (Take A Look At Me Now)": 87%
Tim Urban's "Crazy Little Thing Called Love": 7%

Tied for third place, with 3% of the votes: Siobhan Magnus and Andrew Garcia.

Who will be eliminated tonight?


Paige Miles: 90%
Tim Urban: 4%

Tied for third place, again with 3% of the votes: Andrew Garcia and Lee Dewyze.

Interesting footnote: in those last two polls, absolutely nobody chose Katie Stevens.

Experts' picks for elimination:


For the first time, Abbey and I totally agree on these. Our bottom three:

Andrew Garcia
Katie Stevens
Paige Miles

Abbey thinks Lee Dewyze and Tim Urban could be in danger. I think with the praise he got tonight, Lee will be nowhere near the bottom three--but I was wrong last week.

So we all seem to agree, the person going home: Paige Miles. It's about time, don't you think?


(Image courtesy of Fox)

News from our partners