American Idol Best User Comments!

American Idol Best User Comments!
Tuesday, April 17, 2007

It's that time again! Time to take a look through what some of you readers have had to say about American Idol! We've chosen the most though provoking comments. Will Sanjaya win? Will Simon quit? How about that Princess P? Here's what you had to say about American Idol.

Katrina said: I think that American Idol has turned into a showcase for "cute" young guys. This is a show that is suppose to be about talent, and if I have to watch Sanjaya move on to another round, my TV will be turned off, this contest has become nothing more than a joke. There has been some people elimated who have real talent, not a pearly white smile an nice hair and batting the big brown pretty eyes. Enough, get on with what this contest is meant to be about, TALENT.....not a joke show.

(NB Canada)

Misty said: I think there is something wrong with this voting system for American Idol. I called in and voted twice for the one I liked and it isn't Sanjaya. He doesn't have the talent to go all the way or to make me want to buy his album. GET HIM OFF THE SHOW!!!!! And Simon, I can't blame you for wanting ot leave if he wins. I WOULD TOO!!!!

(Lebanon, Ohio)

Remy said: Paris is obviously taken out of context. AI has lost its taste, no question about it, and the huge gap in talent is the result of the PRODUCERS & JUDGES WHO ARE OBVIOUSLY PUTTING TOGETHER A "WINNING FORMULA," to lure viewers. We have/had the ROCKER CHICK, FAGGY POP BOY, SOUL DIVA, SOULFUL WHITE BOI, ETC.) A real and true Artistic Talent like Miss Paris has every right to voice her objection to the Coke sipping corprate lackeys who've sacraficed Talent for Fromula. Further you dim wit, LOYALTY is EARNED by treating people the correct way. Sure, have your lawyers write up a NON DISCLOSURE- NON CIRCUMVENTURE for LIFE for these kids. When that's done, you certainly have something to hide. The joke of this great TV programming is this: We have one contestant who can hold her own with the world's greatest DIVAs; and another, who on merit shouldn't win a elementery school talent show. The people have to look like fools given the choices we have to work with. Go Paris... don't bite the had that made you; GET A HATCHET AND LOP IT'S HEAD OFF UNTIL THE FAT DOLLARS) OOZE OUT. After the brain washing, manipulation and being used and disgarded and degraded for most of the contestants, it's the American way to want to not only keep them quiet about it, but pretened to be grateful too. Jeniffer and Paris BOTH know they MADE that stinking show AS MUCH AS IF NOT MORE THAN IT MADE THEM. Without the really talented ones, no one whould have every watched to start.

(Dallas)

And that's it for this round, what is your opinion? And don't forget to get yourself a profile and start posting, we'd love to have your comments in here next time!

- Jon Lachonis, BuddyTV Senior Writer
(image from FOX)

BuddyTV

Cast Pages

Follow American Idol

Personality Quiz

Send a Gift

News from our partners

Partner Links »

All American Idol Articles »