We are three days from the end. Every American Idol season is a
marathon, an epic event that plods on, no end in sight, for months on end. The massive process
of it all is one of the reasons why American Idol is so appealing.
Once we get to the end, it feels deserved. Adam Lambert and Kris Allen
have earned their spots in the top two. The sample size is adequate,
having separated the real talents from the charlatans, and we are left
with two potential stars. Judging American Idol in its own vacuum, and
not lending any credence to post-Idol potential, the Kris vs. Adam
contest should be a dead heat. Each singer offers wildly different
things to the audience, and it's difficult to imagine many voters
struggling with this decision. Logic would dictate that you're either
an Adam person or a Kris person. With the two-part finale beginning
tomorrow, who has the better shot at winning? What can we expect from
The format of the finale will go like this: Kris and Adam will each perform three songs -
1) Contestants' Favorite - they'll perform a song that they performed already earlier in the season.
2) Simon Fuller's Choice - exectuive producer Simon Full chooses whatever damn song he wants.
3) The Winner's Single - only one of these this year, and it was written by Kara DioGuardi.
There is potential for an unfair fight in the finale, depending on
which singer fits better with the Winner's Single and whether Simon
Fuller makes good choices for both Kris and Adam. With the favoritism that's been
flung Adam's way all season, I wouldn't be surprised to see Adam get a
Beatles song and Kris get something by Ace of Base.
Yeah - Adam Lambert is a huge favorite to win. But, so was David
Archuleta at one point last season. You can't find two more disparate
people than Archie and Lambert, though, so I don't think looking at
past patterns will bring us any meaningful insight. Adam Lambert is a
unique contestant, and so is Kris Allen. Allen is the reason Idol
began allowing instruments in the competition, and he wouldn't have
made it to the finals without his trusty guitar. With Danny Gokey
gone, though, Adam Lambert probably has more detractors than Kris does
(who the hell would ever hate Kris Allen?), but I also suspect Adam has
more fans. Kris, just by the very nature of his being, isn't going to
inspire the passion that Lambert does. Kris is too laid-back, too
normal. I expect Adam to win pretty easily, though there are some
variables that will come into play.
Even though I would generally advise the contestants to choose the song
from their best performance for their pick, I think Kris would be wise
not to sing Kanye two weeks in a row. Adam has a lot of possibilities
reaching back into the season, and I'm guessing he'll either choose
"Mad World," or "Tracks of My Tears." Simon Cowell is another major
wild card. Last year, the crusty Briton played a shrewd reverse
psychology game on America, declaring the final performance episode a
"knock out" for David Archuleta, when it was clearly anything but. This
sated Archie fans while it riled up David Cook fans, and the following
night's results speak for themselves.
Will Cowell try the same gambit this season, or will he allow himself
to be honest and refuse to indulge in any pre-meditated agenda coming into
the finale? Simon has shown a clear preference for Adam over Kris,
though I don't think he has any ill will towards Mr. Allen. Adam has been
lauded by the judges all season, and there's no reason to believe that
will change this week, the only question is to what degree Simon and
the others will heap praise onto Adam and whether they'll be will to do
the same to Kris, if he deserves it.
Stay tuned all week for a ton of American Idol coverage here on BuddyTV. Share your thoughts and predictions below.Read More:
American Idol 8: Disembarking the Anti-Danny Gokey Train
American Idol 8: Season in Review - Danny Gokey
29 Movie Characters Who Could Have Competed on American Idol
American Idol 8: Top 3 Performance Rankings
American Idol 8: John vs. Oscar Podcast - Why Danny Gokey Must Go Home
American Idol 8: Why Adam Lambert Shouldn't Win
American Idol 8: The Three-Headed Man Monster
American Idol 8: Ranking Every Adam Lambert Performance
American Idol 8: Ranking Every Danny Gokey Performance
American Idol 8: Ranking Every Kris Allen Performance
American Idol's Paula Abdul and 107 Other Things Scarier Than Swine Flu-Oscar Dahl, BuddyTV Senior Writer