Peacemaker season 2 ended with an audacious swing that split the room. In the days after the finale, conversation has centered on fan reaction, whether there’s a “secret” ninth episode, and the small but heartfelt connection to the old DCEU that viewers discovered in the closing minutes. Below is a precise rundown of what was said by named voices, the concrete details fans are debating, and what the show itself puts on the board — no guesswork, just what’s onscreen or directly quoted.
Why the ending landed as “mixed reviews”
On October 16, 2025, Comics Beat published a staff roundtable titled “Live from Earth‑X: The Beat’s Peacemaker Season 2 roundtable,” gathering multiple named commentators to react to all eight episodes.
In that conversation, Avery Kaplan said, “Peacemaker Season 2 is easily Gunn’s strongest DCU outing yet,” while also noting disappointment about leaving the Nazi world behind after the penultimate episode. Taimur Dar felt the new run “surpassed Season 1 in so many ways,” adding that aside from a Lex Luthor cameo by Nicholas Hoult, he was “kind of glad the show restrained itself.”
In contrast, Lisa Fernandes declared, “I loved everything about Season 2 of Peacemaker but the ending,” calling it “extremely dicey to leave your show sitting on a perpetual cliffhanger.” Gregory Paul Silber wrote that he “didn’t love Peacemaker season 2 as much” as colleagues but still praised how Judomaster and Harcourt were handled. Jeremy Fuscaldo said, “I would love to see a third season,” and Derrick Crow added, “Absolutely. There’s more than enough story left,” framing the appetite for more even as the season leaves threads hanging.
Another perspective on the temperature check came in a same‑day editorial that states the finale “received mixed reviews,” while arguing that one specific crossover choice would have made the ending sing even more.
Fans asked James Gunn about the backlash — here’s what he actually said
As discussions intensified, fans reached out to DC Studios co‑chair and co‑CEO James Gunn on social media. In a quote repeated in coverage of the finale’s aftermath, Gunn replied, “Never say never. But right now, this is about the future of the DCU.” The comment acknowledges continued interest in a Peacemaker season 3 while reinforcing that the plan is to pay off season 2’s threads elsewhere in the shared universe.
That same clarification dovetails with how the finale positions its characters and settings. Season 2 ends by introducing “Salvation,” described as an alternate world used as a metahuman prison, and by reconstituting Amanda Waller’s sphere of influence through Checkmate — narrative decisions that point toward future DCU entries rather than a conventional show‑contained wrap‑up.
About that “secret episode” theory (and why fans thought episode 9 existed)
In the week of the finale, a rumor swirled that a “secret” ninth chapter was coming. The theory spread via a fabricated image purporting to show a Threads post from Gunn promising an extra episode. Coverage debunked the screenshot and states it plainly: “No, there is no Peacemaker season 2 episode 9.” The season ends with episode 8, “Full Nelson,” and there isn’t a hidden chapter waiting to drop.
Why did a ninth feel plausible to some viewers? The finale functions like a character waypoint more than a traditional climax, which led sections of the audience to read it as a penultimate step. That structure is deliberate, with resolution designed to land in other DCU projects.
View this post on Instagram
The finale’s easter egg: a small desk prop with big meaning
In the closing moments, as the 11th Street Kids set up the new team Checkmate, Emilia Harcourt adds a rabbit‑shaped figure — modeled on in‑universe hero Ultra Bunny — to her desk. Reporting identifies this as a tribute to Joel Kinnaman’s Rick Flag Jr., a pivotal character from the prior continuity who has since been canonized inside the DCU. It’s a subtle nod, but the placement during Checkmate’s formation links Harcourt’s present to the legacy of Task Force X and a fallen ally.
The detail lands alongside more explicit handoffs. By the finale, Lex Luthor is in play — after an earlier on‑screen appearance by Nicholas Hoult — and speculative chatter points toward how those threads could surface alongside David Corenswet’s Man of Steel in a future Superman sequel.
One missed crossover some viewers wanted
Another article argues that the show “could easily have brought another DCU character” into season 2 but chose not to, singling out an idea that would have connected directly to Creature Commandos. The case centers on G.I. Robot, voiced by Sean Gunn, whose programming is laser‑focused on killing Nazis. Because much of season 2 journeys through Earth‑X — a world where the Nazis won WWII — the editorial posits that “G.I. Robot would have had a field day on Earth‑X.” Ultimately, it also lays out sensible reasons for holding that cameo back, including not stealing the spotlight from the live‑action story and avoiding heavy backstory exposition in a different series.
What the finale explicitly shows (and what fans are naming)
- Universe mechanic: The Quantum‑Unfolding Tunnel/Chamber and A.R.G.U.S. handoff become catalysts for the endgame, culminating with Chris Smith entering the metahuman prison world called Salvation.
- Team status: The 11th Street Kids reconfigure around Checkmate, tying their future to Amanda Waller’s long‑running black‑ops orbit. Harcourt’s Ultra Bunny tribute underscores the Rick Flag Jr. connection.
- Villain board: Lex Luthor is active, with Nicholas Hoult already seen earlier in the season; the setup invites speculation about intersections with future Superman stories.
- No “episode 9” drop: The counterfeit Threads image spawned the rumor, but season 2 ends with eight episodes, and “Full Nelson” is the finale.
Cast & creators named in these sources
The conversations and analyses name a long list of principals who define the season’s texture and its DCU handoffs. This section simply records the names that appear in the reporting and roundtable cited above.
- Series lead and characters: John Cena (Christopher “Chris” Smith / Peacemaker); Emilia Harcourt (Jennifer Holland); Leota Adebayo (Danielle Brooks); Adrian Chase / Vigilante (Freddie Stroma); Judomaster (Nhut Le); Eagly (voiced by Dee Bradley Baker).
- Antagonists and DCU figures: Lex Luthor (Nicholas Hoult); Amanda Waller (Viola Davis); Superman (David Corenswet referenced for future plans); General Rick Flag (referenced alongside Rick Flag Jr.); Ultra Bunny (in‑universe hero nod).
- Season‑2 specific locales and concepts: Earth‑X; Salvation; the Quantum‑Unfolding Tunnel/Chamber; A.R.G.U.S.; Checkmate.
- Related DCU project referenced in analysis: Creature Commandos, including G.I. Robot (voiced by Sean Gunn).
- Roundtable contributors whose quoted reactions illustrate the “mixed” reception: Avery Kaplan; Taimur Dar; Lisa Fernandes; Gregory Paul Silber; Jeremy Fuscaldo; Derrick Crow.
How the roundtable’s quotes map to the season’s debate
Kaplan celebrated craft and scale but missed time in the Nazi world after episode 6. Dar praised the season, beating its predecessor, and welcomed restraint on universe‑wide cameos beyond Lex Luthor/Nicholas Hoult. Fernandes loved the journey but disliked ending on a “perpetual cliffhanger.” Silber emphasized growth for Judomaster and Harcourt. Fuscaldo wants a third season eventually, while Crow argued there is “more than enough story” for one. These sentiments — pro, con, and hungry for more — are an organic definition of “mixed reviews.”
What’s next for these threads
Gunn’s “Never say never” line keeps a door ajar for Peacemaker to return, but the immediate roadmap points outward. With Checkmate formalized, a Waller‑centric stop makes thematic sense. The presence of Lex Luthor (Nicholas Hoult) keeps the Superman connections warm. Salvation’s premise — an Earth‑like realm holding metahumans — is a franchise lever that future DCU films or shows can pull without requiring a Peacemaker season 3 order first.
Where to watch
All eight episodes of Peacemaker season 2 are available to stream on HBO Max / Max.
With a collective experience in film analysis and entertainment journalism, our team, comprised of avid movie buffs, has always been on the frontline of exploring cinematic universes, from the enchanting realms of Disney to the action-packed scenes of the MCU.
Our passion has led us to exclusive interviews with notable figures, early access, and active participation in the industry.
Recognized by the press, we dive deep into various genres, including drama, cartoons, comedy, and foreign films, always eager to bring fresh insights to our readers.
Connect with us or explore our journey to learn more about our adventures in unraveling the magic of the big screen.
