Hulu’s new reality dating series Are You My First? puts 21 eligible singles who identify as virgins on a sun-soaked beach to explore first love and, maybe, first-time intimacy. Hosted by Bachelor Nation alums Kaitlyn Bristowe and Colton Underwood, the show blends awkward charm with earnest conversations and has already sparked a flood of fan questions about renewals, relationships, and where to follow the cast.

On August 25, 2025, cohosts Bristowe and Underwood told Swooon they want a Season 2 and teased tweaks to the format. Underwood floated stricter truth checks from the start, while both hosts said the show should remain a supportive “safe place” for late bloomers. They also noted an influx of would-be applicants sliding into their DMs, which bodes well for more casting.

Meanwhile, producers addressed the obvious question—how do you verify everyone is truly a virgin? On August 22, 2025, Variety reported the team’s approach centers on interviews, story vetting, and intent, emphasizing care over gotcha policing. The point, they suggested, is authenticity rather than shaming or spectacle.

As the final episodes landed in August 2025, Us Weekly published a couple’s status check on August 23, 2025, tracking who left together and who fizzled after filming. Some relationships appeared promising; others remained unclear pending public confirmation. As usual, social media breadcrumbs are doing heavy lifting for fans.

Release date and where to watch ‘Are You My First?’

Season 1 premiered on Hulu in August 2025. All episodes are currently streaming. Season 2 has not been announced as of August 25, 2025; however, the hosts’ comments suggest demand and interest remain high, which could influence renewal decisions.

Hosts and format

Bristowe and Underwood guide dates, games, and candid chats that center consent, comfort, and pacing. The season follows 21 virgins on a beach, and the emphasis stays on making choices without pressure. The hosts have been clear that they want the show to be heartfelt and not a punchline.

Cast and social links

For fans who love to follow along in real time, TODAY rounded up the cast’s Instagram handles in August 2025. The list makes it easy to track post-show updates, soft-launches, and any hard-launch relationship news.

Couples status: who’s still together?

Us Weekly assembled a running “who’s still together” check on August 23, 2025. Some couples left the island on a high, but post-filming distance and life logistics remain real hurdles. Expect more clarity as the cast goes public with updates and as reunion-style interviews surface.

What’s next for ‘Are You My First?’

Renewal is TBD. Still, the cohosts’ Season 2 wish list includes earlier truth-checks and more space for vulnerable, judgment-free conversations. Casting interest is already high, and producers told Variety they prioritize sincerity over shock value. Consequently, if Hulu orders Season 2, expect the core DNA—gentle humor, consent-first pacing, and big “firsts”—to stay intact.

Bottom line: Are You My First? leans into an awkwardly sweet energy, featuring two savvy hosts and a compassionate premise. If it returns, expect Season 2 to double down on care and clarity while keeping the fearless firsts that made Are You My First? a buzzy Hulu talking point.

Buddy TV

With a collective experience in film analysis and entertainment journalism, our team, comprised of avid movie buffs, has always been on the frontline of exploring cinematic universes, from the enchanting realms of Disney to the action-packed scenes of the MCU.

Our passion has led us to exclusive interviews with notable figures, early access, and active participation in the industry.

Recognized by the press, we dive deep into various genres, including drama, cartoons, comedy, and foreign films, always eager to bring fresh insights to our readers.

Connect with us or explore our journey to learn more about our adventures in unraveling the magic of the big screen.