495 match-ups left!
32 contestants
link to from anywhere:

Jay Ryan (Beauty and the Beast)

Uploaded by TheEditor
Report Contestant

Penn Badgley (Gossip Girl)

Uploaded by TheEditor
Report Contestant
 

Overall results

1. Ian Somerhalder (The Vampire Diaries)
7842 Votes
Ian Somerhalder (The Vampire Diaries)
2. Jensen Ackles (Supernatural)
7834 Votes
Jensen Ackles (Supernatural)
3. Jared Padalecki (Supernatural)
7680 Votes
Jared Padalecki (Supernatural)
4. Steven R. McQueen (The Vampire Diaries)
6826 Votes
Steven R. McQueen (The Vampire Diaries)
5. Joseph Morgan (The Vampire Diaries)
6811 Votes
Joseph Morgan (The Vampire Diaries)
6. Shane West (Nikita)
6720 Votes
Shane West (Nikita)
7. Zach Roerig (The Vampire Diaries)
6681 Votes
Zach Roerig (The Vampire Diaries)
8. Stephen Amell (Arrow)
6638 Votes
Stephen Amell (Arrow)
9. Michael Trevino (The Vampire Diaries)
6545 Votes
Michael Trevino (The Vampire Diaries)
10. Jay Ryan (Beauty and the Beast)
6532 Votes
Jay Ryan (Beauty and the Beast)
11. Misha Collins (Supernatural)
6471 Votes
Misha Collins (Supernatural)
12. Matt Lanter (90210)
6463 Votes
Matt Lanter (90210)
13. Colin Donnell (Arrow)
6313 Votes
Colin Donnell (Arrow)
14. Devon Sawa (Nikita)
6291 Votes
Devon Sawa (Nikita)
15. Chace Crawford (Gossip Girl)
6259 Votes
Chace Crawford (Gossip Girl)
16. Paul Wesley (The Vampire Diaries)
6067 Votes
Paul Wesley (The Vampire Diaries)
17. Wilson Bethel (Hart of Dixie)
5957 Votes
Wilson Bethel (Hart of Dixie)
18. Justin Hartley (Emily Owens, M.D.)
5875 Votes
Justin Hartley (Emily Owens, M.D.)
19. Dillon Casey (Nikita)
5534 Votes
Dillon Casey (Nikita)
20. Max Brown (Beauty and the Beast)
5388 Votes
Max Brown (Beauty and the Beast)
21. Noah Bean (Nikita)
5249 Votes
Noah Bean (Nikita)
22. Scott Porter (Hart of Dixie)
4835 Votes
Scott Porter (Hart of Dixie)
23. Michael Rady (Emily Owens, M.D.)
4665 Votes
Michael Rady (Emily Owens, M.D.)
24. Penn Badgley (Gossip Girl)
4482 Votes
Penn Badgley (Gossip Girl)
25. Matthew Settle (Gossip Girl)
4452 Votes
Matthew Settle (Gossip Girl)
26. Aaron Stanford (Nikita)
4142 Votes
Aaron Stanford (Nikita)
27. Ed Westwick (Gossip Girl)
3585 Votes
Ed Westwick (Gossip Girl)
28. Trevor Donovan (90210)
3348 Votes
Trevor Donovan (90210)
29. Cress Williams (Hart of Dixie)
3079 Votes
Cress Williams (Hart of Dixie)
30. Michael Steger (90210)
2884 Votes
Michael Steger (90210)
31. Tristan Wilds (90210)
2652 Votes
Tristan Wilds (90210)
32. Rob Evans (America's Next Top Model)
2488 Votes
Rob Evans (America

AbbigailDrinkwater's results

1. Aaron Stanford (Nikita)
Aaron Stanford (Nikita)
2. Colin Donnell (Arrow)
Colin Donnell (Arrow)
3. Jared Padalecki (Supernatural)
Jared Padalecki (Supernatural)
4. Jensen Ackles (Supernatural)
Jensen Ackles (Supernatural)
5. Justin Hartley (Emily Owens, M.D.)
Justin Hartley (Emily Owens, M.D.)
6. Noah Bean (Nikita)
Noah Bean (Nikita)
7. Trevor Donovan (90210)
Trevor Donovan (90210)
8. Chace Crawford (Gossip Girl)
Chace Crawford (Gossip Girl)
9. Devon Sawa (Nikita)
Devon Sawa (Nikita)
10. Ed Westwick (Gossip Girl)
Ed Westwick (Gossip Girl)
11. Ian Somerhalder (The Vampire Diaries)
Ian Somerhalder (The Vampire Diaries)
12. Jay Ryan (Beauty and the Beast)
Jay Ryan (Beauty and the Beast)
13. Joseph Morgan (The Vampire Diaries)
Joseph Morgan (The Vampire Diaries)
14. Matt Lanter (90210)
Matt Lanter (90210)
15. Michael Rady (Emily Owens, M.D.)
Michael Rady (Emily Owens, M.D.)
16. Michael Trevino (The Vampire Diaries)
Michael Trevino (The Vampire Diaries)
17. Misha Collins (Supernatural)
Misha Collins (Supernatural)
18. Stephen Amell (Arrow)
Stephen Amell (Arrow)
19. Steven R. McQueen (The Vampire Diaries)
Steven R. McQueen (The Vampire Diaries)
20. Tristan Wilds (90210)
Tristan Wilds (90210)
21. Wilson Bethel (Hart of Dixie)
Wilson Bethel (Hart of Dixie)
22. Zach Roerig (The Vampire Diaries)
Zach Roerig (The Vampire Diaries)