Emerson, Ned and Chuck investigate the death of Tony DiNapoli, who is suspected to be strangled by a woman. When Ned revives Tony to find out who killed him, Tony says it was Burly Bruce Carter, who used the hands of his "girlfriend," who is a RealDoll. Meanwhile, a new candy store opens in town, forcing the Pie Hole‘s sales to drop. Alfredo continues to pursue Olive, who continues to set her eyes on the Pie Maker.