Earl J. Hickey is a casual thief whose life is messed up. However, things get even more chaotic after he wins a lottery ticket worth $100,000. Upon winning it, though, he gets into a car accident that causes him to lose the ticket. While recovering in the hospital, his wife Joy demands for a divorce. He also is introduced to the idea of karma while watching an interview with singer Trace Adkins on Last Call with Carson Daly. He later decides to make up for all the wrong he had done and makes a list of bad deeds totaling 259. Upon leaving the hospital, he starts to make amends, and gets magnificent results as he finds his lost $100,000 winning ticket. Realizing that karma works wonders, he sets out to make even more amends and discovers that he has feelings for his new beautiful made, Catalina.