Natalie is a 27-year-old human resources recruiter-turned bartender who resides in Chicago. She is one of the 25 ladies who competed for Jason Mesnick in The Bachelor 13. Her time on the reality dating series, however, was short-lived as she was eliminated in the third episode. In 2010, she returned to the small screen as one of the cast members of the first season of Bachelor Pad. Ultimately, she won the competition along with Bachelorette season 5 contestant David Good.