Why is he still a choreographer on this show? I've been disappointed with him every single time he choreographed. Nothing he's ever done has done anything but make me mad that he's on the show. I think that, as Nigel said, he just doesn't really choreograph much, and it really ruins the dances and the couples every time. It's so awkward when it's completely the choreographers fault, because it's not fair since you can't judge the dancers. And it really only happens with Dave. I'd start a petition to get him off the show, but I'd rather have one to get Mia back. On another note, what is it with Tabitha and Napoleon taking out their (pent up?) sexual aggression with every single dance? It seems like all of their dances this season have been about sex. What happened to the "Bleeding Love's," and the chain dance etc.?

p.s. I love Tabitha and Napoleon. I just miss them.

Dude, you've got some temper issue. First off, just chill. Secondly, if you're going to make an accusation against someone, please be specific in your criticism other than giving the general "you suck" speech. I agree that his last choreographed dance was rather disappointing; however, I believe that many more people will agree with me that his last group dance pretty amazing. Also, do you not remember Brandon and Janette's rock vs. hip hop routine from last season? It was highly praised as well. Moreover, his routine for Twitch and Comfort for Season 4 was beyond memorable and amazing. It was so good that it saved Comfort from elimination. In fact, your beloved Nappytabs have slipped too. Their hip hop routine with Noelle and Ryan as well as the one by Karen and Kevin were good in their stories, but not so exciting in their actual dancing. Another choreographer who acted out of people's expectations (in a bad way) is Wade Robson - with his Van Gough-inspired jazz routine.

The bottom line: people slip, so what?

Yes, his group routine was fantastic, and his Comfort and Twitch routine was memorable, but I've found all of his others to be lacking. If you go back and watch Brandon and Jeanette, you'll see that Brandon is just an unbelievably talented dancer and the whole time it was basically just him. Dave Scott even admitted in the pre-dance video that he made up a bunch of those moves for Brandon on the spot. People do slip, but I think it's the other way around with Dave Scott. I think once in every ten routines he gets something good, unlike everyone else who once in every ten makes a mistake.

what in the world are you talking about? dave has only had two bad routines the first being legacy and ashleigh which i agree was dissapointing, and the second being karla and johnathan which was pretty much johnathans fault. He is by far the best HH choreographer on sytycd. and he hasn't even been on the show long enough to choreograph 10 routines. Just chill out. Obviously they wouldn't have him choreographing all these routines since season 3 if he wasn't good!