I think Joanna and Derek were the best. I feel the judges pick the ones they want from the first and then start throwing out high scores for that one person. Joanna and Derek should never have had to go. Love Donny but he should have been better

I totally agree...Joanna was so elegant and she performed so well!

I agree, Donny need it to go. Joanna was 100% better then Donny.

Kelly is cute, but not the best dancer. Donny should have been one of the first to go. The more I see him the less I like him.

Without the costume problem, Donny would likely have had a score very close to Joanna's. American Idol, Britain's Got Talent, America's Got Talent all depend upon the viewers' votes. After all they are the ones who are going to buy the tickets to see these people. Life is about being popular or being what the public wants. I think that her posing in Playboy and Hugh Hefner showing up with his harem hurt Joanna with the public. If you look at the personal stories: Mya is biracial and does work with kids. Donny is considered wholesome and a family man. Kelly overcame drugs. Joanna exploits her sexuality to make money. Also, she wasn't the best dancer of the final four - she came a long way and Derek helped her a lot, but her feet were still awkward.

You have to give Donny a chance and he smiled throughout his performances and it's only his posture and he is trying his best, my people.

Just in case someone misinterprets my comment about Mya being bi-racial. I meant that she has likely had to overcome a lot of obstacles. I read her bio and she's quite a determined woman, which shows up in her work on the show. Donny is still my pick, but I do admire all the work that everyone has done on the show. Like I said - I think that the Playboy/Hugh Hefner thing hurt Joanna. I think that the next person eliminated will be Kelly and IF Donny comes up with 9s, he will win, even if Mya gets 10s. IMHO.

I agree that Joanna's Playboy shoot did hurt her. People do not like a winner who they can not respect.

Way better dancer then Don, Or I mean DONNY!!! Last year I tune in. All it has become is a popularity contest.

I also think the Playboy spread hurt Joanna. I saw it on ET and it turned me off. Donny is a clean cut guy who has always set a good example. It's nice to see a "good guy" still in the running. I have voted for him and will continue to do so. He and Mya should be in the final two. Of them, Mya is the better dancer but I think she's a professional.