The Good, the Bad and the Ugly: Comedy in 2010
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly: Comedy in 2010
John Kubicek
John Kubicek
Senior Writer, BuddyTV
Welcome to The GBU, a weekly column coming every Monday where I look at the Good, the Bad and the Ugly on TV.

December is a time to look back at the year that was in television, and now it's time for comedy. Modern Family won the Emmy for Outstanding Comedy, 30 Rock went live and Louie C.K. made me laugh a whole lot over the summer.

Not all titles featured on BuddyTV are available through Amazon Prime.


Here's the Good, the Bad and the Ugly of comedy in 2010.

The Good: Dan Harmon and the Writers of Community

gbu-comedy-comm.JPGNo other show on TV comes close to the insane cleverness of Community in 2010. Episodes about paintball, zombies and mean girls are just a few examples of the way this show reinvents sitcom premises and revels in the kind of ingenuity and inspiration you typically see on the Internet. $#*! My Dad Says might be inspired by a Twitter feed, but Community is a far better representation of the tone of modern pop culture.

The Bad: Edie Falco Winning the Emmy

gbu-comedy-nursejackie.jpgI love Edie Falco, and I actually enjoy Nurse Jackie quite a bit. But it is NOT a comedy. I understand that, for the Emmys, a show that's only a half-hour might seem like a comedy. But there's almost nothing funny about the show and definitely nothing funny about Falco's pill-popping adulteress Jackie Peyton. Falco even admitted as much during her acceptance speech, stating "I'm not funny." So while it might be a good show, it's bad for comedy to let these kinds of performances beat out genuinely funny ladies.
 
The Ugly: What SNL Did to Bryan Cranston

gbu-comedy-snl.jpgSometimes Emmy-winning stars like Jon Hamm and Alec Baldwin are perfect for SNL, but at the start of this season the show booked three-time Emmy winner Bryan Cranston, a man who has consistantly delivered an amazing performance on Breaking Bad and who, before that, rpvoed how funny he is on Malcolm in the Middle. Yet watching him host SNL was like torture, seeing this genuinely talented and funny man forced to do unfunny comedy. It was painful, embarrassing and just plain ugly.


(Images courtesy of NBC, Showtime and CBS)

News from our partners