Without Tim Urban to kick around, American Idol
voters are forced
to eliminate someone who can actually sing tonight. This week Abbey
Simmons and I debate the Top 6, and while Abbey thinks the "twain" has
left the station, I feel more like Anna Karenina at the end of the book.
Read Abbey's Recap of the Top 6 Performances>>
However, despite our disagreements on the four guys, we agree on the
fact that the two remaining girls did not have a great week and that
Crystal Bowersox's boyfriend is the unluckiest man in America.
Listen to our full podcast or continue below for the highlights.