America's Next Top Model: Part Two of All-Stars Showdown!
Today we are wrapping up our model-off between the eight winners of the first eight cycles of America’s Next Top Model.

Once again, for this little exercise, there are four categories – Editorial, Commercial, Height (with two points per inch deducted for each inch outside the typical range of 5’9” to 5’11”), and Runway.  There are ten points possible in each category and the four scores are averaged.

For the rankings, I reviewed all of the winner’s America’s Next Top Model photos, as well as their finale runway walk and most of the runway challenges.

As best as I could, I tried to look at their output without taking into account their personality too much. Sometimes, like for an Eva Pigford, for example, they have so much personality it’s hard for that not to translate into a more engaging picture. But in some cases, I was surprised to see how strong the photos were for some of the modelettes who hadn’t really come across as likable or dynamic in the series.

Our top four have two set of ties. The two who tied with the highest score came as a total surprise to me and might even be a little controversial to hardcore America’s Next Top Model fans. Click below to see the results!

Next >>

America's Next Top Model: Part One of All-Stars Showdown!

- Leslie Seaton, BuddyTV Staff Columnist
(Image courtesy of CW)