John vs. Abbey: The Great Andrew Garcia Debate
John Kubicek
John Kubicek
Senior Writer, BuddyTV
It's another week of deadly American Idol competition between myself and Abbey Simmons, and this time, it's even deadlier.  While we basically agree on the girls this week, there's a vicious battle brewing over the guys and whether singers like Andrew Garcia are terrible or genius.

Top 8 Guys Performances>>
Top 8 Girls Performances>>

Listen to the full podcast for the following debates:

-Why Crystal Bowersox should win and headline Lilith Fair with Kelly Clarkson

-Why Paige Miles and Katie Stevens are doomed, and whether Paige's "Smile" was the absolute worst performance of the season

-Why I think Andrew Garcia's "Genie in a Bottle" was genius, and why Abbey thinks I'm an absolute idiot for thinking this

-Why I still love Aaron Kelly, and why Abbey thinks he'll be going home this week

-Why Mike Lynche is the new Ruben Studdard, why Alex Lambert is the new Taylor Hicks, and why these are not good things

-Why Lee Dewyze needs to stop singing d-bag songs

(Image courtesy of FOX)