It's another week of deadly American Idol competition between myself and Abbey Simmons, and this time, it's even deadlier.  While we basically agree on the girls this week, there's a vicious battle brewing over the guys and whether singers like Andrew Garcia are terrible or genius.

Top 8 Guys Performances>>
Top 8 Girls Performances>>

Listen to the full podcast for the following debates:




-Why Crystal Bowersox should win and headline Lilith Fair with Kelly Clarkson

-Why Paige Miles and Katie Stevens are doomed, and whether Paige's "Smile" was the absolute worst performance of the season

-Why I think Andrew Garcia's "Genie in a Bottle" was genius, and why Abbey thinks I'm an absolute idiot for thinking this

-Why I still love Aaron Kelly, and why Abbey thinks he'll be going home this week

-Why Mike Lynche is the new Ruben Studdard, why Alex Lambert is the new Taylor Hicks, and why these are not good things

-Why Lee Dewyze needs to stop singing d-bag songs


(Image courtesy of FOX)