There were some bad performances on
American Idol this season. This is the case, of course, every season. However, I'd argue that on most
American Idol years, the poor performances are given by the same people, over and over again, until those singers are eliminated. This season, in that regard, was a little different. For whatever reason, many of the top 10 finalists on
American Idol 7 were severely hit and miss. Take
Brooke White,
David Archuleta and
Jason Castro. Their best performances were awe-inspiring, their worst were dreadful. We had some consistent performers (
David Cook...uh, I guess that's it), but this will probably go down as the season of the inconsistent. Thanks to help from you, the BuddyTV readers, we've compiled the top 10 worst performances from this past Idol season.
Your Take
wndlou said:
Hey KennyChan8, Take a chill pill! We're all just having some fun here! I'll say it straight! I AM A COO...
SueBrody2 said:
David Cook has had one pretty mediocre performance (was it Seven Mary Three?) and the others have been good...
KaKayKayla said:
Let's go David COOK!! him and michael johns were the best~
Constructing a list like this is difficult. You take your own opinion into account, sure, but you also have to listen to the general public. Only two singers cracked the top ten more than once, and they probably won't be who you expect. I incorporated expectations into the list, as well, holding the better singers to a higher standard than the
Kristy Lee Cooks of the world. You won't find
Chikezie Eze or
Ramiele Malubay on this list, for instance, because, for the most part, they were consistently OK. I was looking for out and out train wrecks, the kind of performances that make you angry and sad and baffled.
For every entry in the top 10, we've included a YouTube video of the performance. The video evidence, if I may say so, is hard to argue with. I tried to keep performances from the Top 24 to a minimum, but a few were so bad that they had to be included. Looking back, I'm glad I didn't have to make this list last year, because it would have consisted of at least eight
Sanjaya Malakar performances. Thankfully, we had no Sanjayas this year. Enjoy the list, and feel free to comment away.
NEXT>>
Also Read
John vs. Oscar: Finale Predictions
Finale Performance Rankings
Finale Performance Live Thoughts
Why David Archuleta Will Win
Why David Cook Will Win
May the Best Man Lose
Best Performances of Season 7
-Oscar Dahl, BuddyTV Senior Writer
(Image Courtesy of FOX)