Last night American Idol finally felt like American Idol. All six contestants could sing and almost all of them brought their own spin to their songs. For the first time all season, artistry outweighed karaoke. It was a beautiful thing. Unfortunately what made last night good is exactly makes tonight‘s elimination the most difficult yet. Just like Rod Stewart sang ... the 19th cut is the deepest. Who was the best of the best performance show yet? See our performance rankings. Will Big Mike‘s second chance come to an end tonight? Will "High School student" Aaron Kelly be sent back to homeroom? Will Siobhan‘s screeching signal her demise? We have
Read more »